| Platinum | Perry's Pizza |
| Gold | Johnny's Saloon |
| Silver | Stoney's Pizza Hb |
| Bronze | Buon Gusto |
| Top Pick | BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse |
| Top Pick | California Pizza Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Massimo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Round Table Pizza |
| Top Pick | Zerozero39 Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Zubies Dry Dock |
| Golden Olive |