| Platinum | Mona Lisa Cucina |
| Gold | Perry's Pizza |
| Silver | Buon Gusto |
| Bronze | Capone's Italian Cucina |
| Top Pick | Caffe Gazelle |
| Top Pick | Mangia-Mangia |
| Top Pick | Piccolo Stivale |
| Top Pick | Pizza D'Oro |
| Top Pick | Sebastiani's Italian Bistro |
| Top Pick | Zerozero39 Pizzeria |